Judging Q and saving Jesus – Q’s contribution to the wisdom- apocalypticism debate in historical Jesus studies

Judging Q and saving Jesus – Q’s contribution to the wisdom- apocalypticism debate in historical Jesus studies

1 Ungluer has Faved this Work

Judging Q and saving Jesus is characterised by careful textual analysis, showing a piercing critical eye in its impressive engagement with the secondary literature, and sharp and insightful critique. The target audience are specialists in the field of research on the Sayings Source Q (the hypothetical source of certain sayings of Jesus common to Matthew and Luke), historical Jesus, and early Christian theology. The book takes the stance that the hypothetical document Q can be reconstructed with sufficient precision and that this enables biblical scholars to study with confidence its genre and its thematic and ideological profile. The genre issue is central to the book overall structure and the alternative proposals are discussed at length and with sophistication. The author’s inference is that Q’s macrogenre is sapiential with occasional insertions of apocalyptic microstructures and motifs. This finding embodies progress in Historical Jesus studies. An opposing trend has been to label Jesus an apocalypticist, so that the great ‘either-or’ of contemporary Jesus scholarship has been ‘either eschatological or not’, an alternative that dates back to Albert Schweitzer.

The author finds that generally, and even when used apocalyptically, the term Son of Man tends to support arguments best understood as sapiential in outlook. This is consistent with the sapiential genre of the document as a whole. This finding is supported by the close and careful exegesis of Q 6:37−38 (on not judging). He reconstructs the original wording of this saying ‘on not judging’ and explores the idea of ‘weighing’ in judgment (psychostasia), determining in the end that the saying is entirely sapiential.

This book is included in DOAB.

Why read this book? Have your say.

You must be logged in to comment.

Rights Information

Are you the author or publisher of this work? If so, you can claim it as yours by registering as an rights holder.


This work has been downloaded 465 times via ebook links.
  1. 55 - pdf (CC BY-NC) at
  2. 55 - pdf (CC BY-NC) at OAPEN Library.
  3. 65 - pdf (CC BY-NC) at OAPEN Library.
  4. 112 - pdf (CC BY-NC-SA) at OAPEN Library.
  5. 178 - pdf (CC BY-NC-SA) at Internet Archive.


  • Apocalyptic
  • Apokaliptiese
  • Do not judge
  • Documentary status
  • Eschatological
  • Eskatologiese
  • Historical Jesus
  • Historiese Jesus
  • Jesus
  • judgement
  • Judgment
  • Judgment / Judgement
  • KUnlatched
  • Moenie oordeel
  • New Quest
  • New Testament
  • Old Quest
  • Oordeel
  • Psychostasia
  • Q
  • Religion
  • Religion / Biblical Studies
  • Religion / Biblical Studies / New Testament
  • religious studies
  • Sayings Gospel
  • Son of Man
  • Theology
  • Wisdom
  • wysheid


DOI: 10.4102/aosis.jqsj.2015.01


edition cover


Copy/paste this into your site: